First of all, I would check all my credit history in all other banks, maybe it's all about you and your financial issues. Or, if everything is okay, maybe you should simply look for another bank. Or as an option, you can always take a look at articles like american express aeroplan card one, where you can read everything about that exact type of credit card, and compare it with others.
Instead of spending hundreds of hours of my personal time, I would rather ask someone who knows better than me - how to resolve that jural issues. From the reviews, that I've read, I can say for sure that this firm ( here: https://federal-lawyer.com/new-york/new-york-city-federal-defense/ ), is one of those law companies, where I would hire a lawyer if I would have an urge of him or her.